TMDBUser rating

Top Rated Mystery TV Shows

Browse the highest-rated mystery TV shows on TMDB with a minimum vote threshold.

Methodology

Sorted by TMDB user rating in descending order and filtered to Mystery shows with at least 200 votes. All premiere years are included.

Ranking Rules

Genre filter applied · Minimum votes: 200

Updated: Jul 1, 2026, 10:45 PM

Taken7.5

Taken

2002-12-02

Medium7.5

Medium

2005-01-03

Poker Face7.5

Poker Face

2023-01-26

Yellowjackets7.5

Yellowjackets

2021-11-14

Agatha All Along7.5

Agatha All Along

2024-09-18

Damages7.4

Damages

2007-07-24

Preacher7.4

Preacher

2016-05-22

Creepshow7.4

Creepshow

2019-09-26

Santa Clarita Diet7.4

Santa Clarita Diet

2017-02-03

The Returned7.4

The Returned

2012-11-26

Sleepy Hollow7.4

Sleepy Hollow

2013-09-16

Jericho7.4

Jericho

2006-09-20

Swamp Thing7.4

Swamp Thing

2019-05-31

A Series of Unfortunate Events7.4

A Series of Unfortunate Events

2017-01-13

River7.4

River

2015-10-13

Cruel Summer7.4

Cruel Summer

2021-04-20

The Worst Witch7.4

The Worst Witch

2017-01-11

The Outsider7.4

The Outsider

2020-01-12

The Terror7.4

The Terror

2018-03-26

The Pretender7.4

The Pretender

1996-09-19

Browse more rankings

2026 PopularTop RatedSci-Fi Top RatedCrime Top RatedDrama Top RatedNetflix 2026HBO 2026Max 2026Apple TV+ 2026Disney+ 2026Prime Video 2026